Showing posts with label atheism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label atheism. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 12, 2019

Skeptic-ing





Every man who thinks and lives by thought must have his own skepticism, that which stops at the question, that which ends in denial, or that which leads to faith and which is somehow integrated into the faith which transcends it.

                                         -T.S. Eliot, Intro to Pascal's Pensées

Tuesday, January 7, 2014

The Pessimist



Not many years ago when I was an atheist, if anyone had asked me, ‘Why do you not believe in God?’ my reply would have run something like this:  ‘Look at the universe we live in.  By far the greatest part of it consists of empty space, completely dark and unimaginably cold...Earth herself existed without life for millions of years and may exist for millions more when life has left her.  And what is it like while it lasts?  It is so arranged that all the forms of it can live only by preying upon one another.  In the lower forms this process entails only death, but in the higher there appears a new quality called consciousness which enables it to be attended with pain...In the most complex of all creatures, Man, yet another quality appears, which we call reason, whereby he is enabled to foresee his own pain which henceforth is preceded with acute mental suffering, and to foresee his own death while keenly desiring permanence.  It also enables men by a hundred ingenious contrivances to inflict a great deal more pain than they otherwise could have done...Every race that comes into being in any part of the universe is doomed; for the universe, they tell us, is running down...All stories will come to nothing: all life will turn out in the end to have been a transitory and senseless contortion upon the idiotic face of infinite matter.  If you ask me to believe that this is the work of a benevolent and omnipotent spirit, I reply that all the evidence points in the opposite direction.  Either there is no spirit behind the universe, or else a spirit indifferent to good and evil, or else an evil spirit.’

There was one question which I never dreamed of raising.  I never noticed that the very strength and facility of the pessimists’ case at once poses us a problem.  If the universe is so bad, or even half so bad, how on earth did human beings ever come to attribute it to the activity of a wise and good Creator?  Men are fools, perhaps; but hardly so foolish as that.  The direct inference from black to white, from evil flower to virtuous root, from senseless work to a workman infinitely wise, staggers belief.  The spectacle of the universe as revealed by experience can never have been the ground of religion: it must always have been something in spite of which religion, acquired from a different source, was held.

CS Lewis, The Problem of Pain

Monday, September 26, 2011

Apologizing


Do you think that you have discovered something new and unusual in your doubts towards the teachings of the church and of the scripture?  You have questioned God and said:  how can a loving God cause or allow all of the bad things that I see to happen?

Religious people, trying to defend God, have made excuses for God in an attempt to answer this question.  The apologist goes to the world to apologize for the sins of God.  We are told to have patience with God, to forgive God.

But what of God’s word to us?  Has not God answered this question, surely burning on the hearts of people since the beginning of time?

No.

The word from God does not answer this question!  It is silent.  You can look and search in your bible and you will not find the answer.  You can find people asking the question.  You can find some peoples’ answer to the question, just like anywhere and anytime you could find peoples’ answers to the questions of the day. 

Most of the book of Job in the bible is Job asking this question of God.  His friends take up chapter after chapter giving their weak an hollow answers, expounding and “apologizing” and criticizing with great poetry and structure and argument.  And yet at the end of it all, God tells them they are ignorant, proud, and wasting time with their speeches.  And when you expect God to answer, he does not, at least not a direct answer, an explanation, as we would request of him.

Then what do we do, where do we go with this question?

Perhaps God is answering, through a story.  A story that requires listening to God.  That we give God our attention for a moment instead of insisting that all eyes stay on ourselves and our questions.

And it turns out that God does have a story. A love story.  An adventure story.  A story of sacrifice, of death and destruction, of life and forgiveness.  A story for all times and all places.  It is the story of God.  Nowhere does God say “stop asking your questions.”  But listening to a story does require a certain pause in one’s speech.  And an honest question does pause for an answer does it not?

Sunday, October 25, 2009

Powerful Ideas, Powerful Artists, Bad Choices



I just finished reading “Growth of the Soil” by Knut Hamsun. My sister, who is always giving me books to read, insisted I read this one she then leant to me. She made me promise that I would not look up or read anything about the author until I was finished reading the book, so as to not spoil the reading. So of course I suspected that he held some sort of political viewpoint or moral stance that she knew I would be against.

The book is wonderfully written. Unique in capturing you and transporting you into the woods with the Norwegian settlers, working the soil and entwining their lives with nature and each other, a great capturing of the complexities of persons, society, and the wilderness. A truly thoughtful and enjoyable read, thanks sis.

It did not take me long to suspect that Mr. Hamsun was a Nazi sympathizer. The story suggested the correct time frame. Norway was essentially taken over by Germany. And some essential elements of a National Socialist idealist are in the author’s thoughts:
-glorification of hard work
-honoring the simple, hard worker, especially the Aryan
-that morals are only means to adapt to society and to the world, not transcendent laws of God. Thus morals are relative and up to question.
-that human life, like morals, has little inherent value. Only what people make of themselves counts
-that there is a conspiracy of oppression to be found in Western capitalism, organized by the Jews, supported by England and America, which draws people away from their true meaning—hard work and a pure, natural life (this was only really found in the last chapter so blatantly)

In these days, in my circles, it is easy to gloss over the temptations to Nazi thinking. We view the Nazi’s as some sort of sub-human, like Orcs from Lord of the Rings, that would stand out so obviously in their moral deprivation that no one in their right mind would follow them. But in reality, some of the seeds of National Socialism are in those ideas of Hamsun, not dissimilar to many a thinker and writer today: truth is relative, morals are relative and tools rather than guides, “mother earth” is the wise teacher and guide, the “big economies” of the world are conspiring to suppress the rest, and globalize us all into idiocy and dehumanize us.

Ever since Adam and Eve, Lucifer has tempted men and women with the worship of the things, the seeking of the things, rather than of God. In this case, it is the worship of man, especially in his wonderful complexity, and his youthful, energetic connection with a life of connection with and working of the land. A wonderful thing it is, when man and beast work and produce the crops. And oh so “natural” and certainly common for man, to worship the crop, the cow, the sun. To sacrifice even to those things on which he depends. New and strange really, is the message that there is a God bigger than—and in a way separate from--the man-nature relationship. Foreign, opposite, is the notion that God wishes us to worship God, and not the wonderful things and wonderful people that He creates and provides.

Knut Hamsun Link
Wikipedia on Hamsun
"Growth of the Soil" Link

Thursday, October 8, 2009

Creed

LinkLink to Steve Turner's Poem "Creed"
Is there room for creeds in the world?

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

Stories and Theories


"We have educated ourselves into imbecility" -Malcolm Muggeridge



And so it comes down to a story. A story of a people, called by God, to be his representatives in the world. A story of dreams, burning bushes, plagues. A story of family dysfunctions, marriages, births, deaths. And a story of God deciding, revealing, instructing, judging. For a theory and a discussion is just that. To reach us, and to reach God, and to put us together, that takes real events with real people and a real god.

It is the insane who live in theories, ignoring the realities of the world they live in, ignoring the realities of themselves and of God. Thinking they are God, they create in their minds a world of make-believe around them to shore up their beliefs.

Darwin and Sagan, they have wonderful facts and discoveries to show. But when Dawkins jumps the chasm to the story part, he does a horrible job. He grows his theories up outside of where they are meant to be. Like a cancer, they run amok in the minds of those who are not shrewd enough to see, toppling reason itself in the very pursuit of it.

One must decide. Not between theory and story. But whether one will read the story and thereby have a world for the theory. Or whether one will try to use the theory for a story and lose both.

Sunday, August 23, 2009

The Bible is Full of Contradictions


Like any good book, like any honest person. Most of the most glaring contradictions I find not between some old book from Moses and another from Paul. But within a few verses of one another. Here is one example:

(Proverbs 10:3-5)

When it comes to food and provisions, Solomon says that it is the Lord that prevents the righteous from going hungry. Yet in the very next verse it says that “lazy hands make a man poor, but diligent hands bring wealth.” So, in other words, it is the hard-working nature of a person that makes them to be able to eat. Yet again, in the very following verse it says that the one who gathers crops in the summer is wise, but the one who sleeps through the harvest is disgraceful.

So what is it? What is the thing that brings provision? That brings wealth? What is it that brings poverty? That causes hunger? These are extremely important questions. Solomon first says that it is the Lord who provides. Suggesting we need to trust the Lord and He will give us all of our provisions.

But the next verse says lazy hands make a man poor. Cause and effect, this is one of the main pillars of scientific thought. In this case: Work, and you will get things. Sit around, and you will wind up poor.

And the next verse adds another twist: the relationship of the child with the parent is what is relevant here, not cause and effect, not God providing. But very simply honor versus disgrace to the family.

How is it that three of these competing interpretations of reality can all coexist? How can reality have cause-and-effect science, a family-centered hierarchy of honor and disgrace, and God’s provision the key to trust, all at once?

The answer is: all are true. Not true in the sense of separate components of a whole, but really three whole explanations that are completely true in themselves, but non-negating of the other truths. That is to say: cause and effect is completely true. There is not some cause-and-effect in observed phenomenon, and that which cannot be explained by cause and effect is attributed to God or to the human spirit, or something of that sort. No, if you observe phenomena, you will find cause and effect going on. If you look for the missing causes, the missing effects, you will find them. That is the structure of the universe.

And the reality of the person is a complete reality, the person in relationship. In this case relationship with the family. The person in honor, the person in disgrace. The person with a real, bona fide existence as an unexplainable being despite your best explanations. The person with an immeasurable soul in a world of measuring sticks.

And you have God. God acting in the world: constantly, consciously, purposefully, lovingly. Not a God of the missing pieces, the parts we have not explained yet. Not a God of the origins only, the clockmaker uninvolved. But God, knowing, relating, intervening.

***

My friend, if you are looking for God by searching for a missing piece, you will not find Him. For from the beginning you are looking for a smaller being that that which He is. If you look for a whale in a microscope, you will not see it, though the microscope is pointing in the right direction. God is not there filling in the gaps of science, holding things together until a new discovery can be made to explain Him away. If that is your concept of God, whether you believe in Him or not, it is in error. This is why the evolutionist battles the creationist over the fossil record: The evolutionists shows that the “missing link” has been found thus disproving the creationist’s theory. The creationist looks for another “missing link” to show the evolutionist that his theory is wrong and he must believe in God. Both are discussing fantasies, for God the creator is so glorious that He has made the world at once smooth without ruffles, and at the same time with an endless thoroughly saturated layer of His own fingerprints. If those fighting would pause long enough, they would behold together the glory of the dinosaur pointing to the glory of God, and would revel in both.

Tuesday, July 28, 2009

Put Up Your Dukes


Put Up Your Dukes

Come on, let’s see ‘em. I want to fight that science-worshiper, and show him (or her) what he is missing! But it seems more the argument of the Christian is not lost by point and counterpoint. No, it is lost when no one sees the point. The point of having the discussion in the first place. The unbeliever for her part is brought up, in church or out, with an underlying current of philosophy that considers God as irrelevant as the Tooth Fairy. A myth, a story, one of many, maybe some truth to it, maybe not, not really important enough to bother with. The Christian for her part shyly flits about this world, trying not to make too many ripples. Earbuds in the ears—Christian music mind you—but quiet so as not to disturb the peaceful underlying philosophy, which she shares with the unbeliever. That which says God is irrelevant. Oh sure, the Christian would say God is relevant to him. He is well-trained to speak of his experiences with God. But if a problem arises, does go to God to solve it? No, he goes to science. He goes to the local expert. He goes to the Internet. Not once pausing to thank his “Lord” for these tools.

But the Christian is angry at the scientist for stating that there is no God. Well, Christian, what of it? Your actions, your appearance, your language, your daily life, all hide God. You work hard to do so actually. So if the scientist says God is missing, have you blocked his view?

But, back to the scientist: science-worshiper or not. Let go of the microscope and the scale for a moment, and see what you are actually measuring. Step back and let it sink in. Fantastic, isn’t it? It is worth taking some time to contemplate, for there is evidence of something more. Something immeasurable. Are you ready for the fight?